2024 Publication: The Valley of Death: Bringing Biotechnology Out of the Lab and Into the Field
Written by Kate Carline, Ethan Chiu, Joshua Zhu
The Valley of Death examines the critical barriers and opportunities within the biotechnology sector, focusing on the United States' competitive positioning against the People’s Republic of China (PRC). It identifies three primary challenges—limited access to high-quality biodata, the financial and regulatory hurdles facing biotech startups, and outdated patent frameworks exacerbated by AI-driven innovations. By analyzing historical and current policy landscapes, the study highlights the U.S.’s early leadership in biotech, now threatened by the PRC’s substantial investments and centralized strategies. Case studies of CRISPR startups reveal trends in successful ventures, emphasizing the importance of academic-industry partnerships and targeted funding. The paper also explores the dual-use dilemma of emerging technologies like AI in drug discovery and patent extensions, proposing strategic recommendations to enhance U.S. innovation, foster collaboration, and mitigate ethical and economic risks. These insights aim to bridge the "Valley of Death," ensuring sustainable growth and global leadership in the bioeconomy.
An Interdisciplinary Approach
Pilot Startup Database
Initial data analysis of 18 CRISPR Startups from around the world with focus on geography, network ties, financial support, and innovation goals to identify the critical factors for bringing startups across the valley of death.
Policy Analysis
Policy analysis of three key blocks to biotechnology development: the integration of biodata, startup viability, and adaptable patents. The paper provides critical comparative analysis of these chokepoints between the PRC and the US, providing policy recommendations to the US on the path forward.
Case Studies
Interviews and case studies of biotechnology development in the US to identify trends in successful biotechnology ventures. Factors such as geographic proximity to research institutions, investment sources, and areas of technological focus are analyzed.